Party boat vs private charter: which fishing trip should you book?

A party boat costs a fraction of a private charter, and it can be a great day or a crowded one. How the two really compare, and who each one suits.

FishTripFinder team 4 min read
Party boat vs private charter: which fishing trip should you book?
Photo: bluesky-1 / Freepik

Walk down any big charter dock in Florida or on the Gulf early in the morning and you’ll see both kinds of trips getting ready. A 65-foot boat with forty people lined up along the rail, and next to it a 30-foot center console with one family of four and a captain. Same water, same fish, very different days.

What a party boat is

A party boat, also called a head boat because you pay by the head, sells individual tickets. You turn up, pay per person and fish alongside everybody else who bought a ticket that morning. Most run half-day (4–5 hours) or full-day trips and do mostly bottom fishing over reefs and wrecks, using heavy rods the boat provides.

Mates walk the rail baiting hooks, untangling lines and gaffing fish. Tickets usually cost $60–$150 for an adult, with discounts for kids on many boats.

What a private charter is

On a private charter you book the whole boat. Most private boats are “six-packs”, meaning the captain’s license allows up to six paying passengers. Bigger inspected boats can take more. The captain plans the day around your group: what you fish for, where you go and how long you stay in one spot.

Party boat vs private charter, side by side

Party boatPrivate charter
Price$60–$150 per person$450–$2,500+ for the boat
Who’s aboard20 to 100+ people you don’t knowYour group only, usually up to 6
FishingMostly bottom fishingYour choice: inshore, reef, trolling, fly
Crew attentionShared with everyoneAll yours
ScheduleFixed departure and returnFlexible within the trip length
BookingOften same day or walk-upDays to months ahead
RideBig boats are usually steadierSmall boats feel the waves more

When a party boat makes sense

  • You’re on your own or there are two of you, and a private boat would cost $400+ a head.
  • You want to try deep sea fishing without committing $1,500 to find out whether you like it.
  • You have kids around 8 or older who’ve fished a bit and want to catch a lot of fish. Bottom fishing keeps them busy.
  • Someone worries about seasickness. A big, heavy boat rolls a lot less than a small one in the same chop.
  • You’re deciding the night before. Many party boats take walk-ups when they have space.

When to pay for a private charter

  • There are four to six of you. Split six ways, the per-person cost gets close to a party-boat ticket plus tip.
  • You want a specific fish: tarpon, redfish on the flats, sailfish, tuna. Party boats can’t chase one species for you.
  • You have small children, beginners or anyone who needs a patient person standing next to them.
  • You want to learn: how to cast, read water or fight a big fish properly.
  • It’s a birthday, a bachelor party or a once-a-year family trip and you want the day to be yours.

How to have a good day on a party boat

  • Get there early. On many boats rail spots are first come, first served. The stern corners are popular because your line has more room.
  • Ask about the jackpot. Lots of party boats run an optional pool for the biggest fish of the trip. Cheap fun, especially with kids.
  • Watch your neighbors’ lines. When someone hooks a big fish, reel in if the mate asks you to. Tangles cost everyone fishing time.
  • Bring a small cooler or bag for your catch. Some boats bag fish by number. Others leave it to you.
  • Tip the mate who helped you. 15–20% of your ticket is the usual guide. More if they spent half the trip with your kids. See our tipping guide.

The in-between option: split charters

Some captains sell individual seats on a small boat, four to six anglers at most, for roughly $150–$350 a seat. You get much more room and attention than on a party boat without paying for the whole boat. They aren’t always advertised, so ask the captains in the town you’re visiting.

Not sure? Ask yourself what matters more on the day: price or control. If it’s price, take the party boat. If you care about what you fish for, who you fish with and when you come back in, book the boat to yourselves.

Party boats on FishTripFinder

Miss Kathleen fishing charter in Ocean City, MD
Ocean City, MD

Miss Kathleen

Deep Sea
Fish On Fishing fishing charter in East Moriches, NY
East Moriches, NY

Fish On Fishing

Deep Sea

See all party boat trips, or browse private charters in the town you’re visiting. For a ballpark of what private boats cost, read inshore vs offshore fishing.

Seasons and regulations change; always check current rules before you fish.

Keep reading

More fishing guides

All guides